Lindsay is a dentist who seems to have it all. She has great friends, a good job and a family that cares about her. What she does not have is a boyfriend to share them with. Armed with her single friend Heather, they go all out searching to meet the guy of their dreams. There’s just one catch. They both want to meet nice Jewish guys. In order to meet new guys, Heather talks Lindsay into trying singles events and the dreaded Internet. When Lindsay finally does meet someone, Dan, she is ecstatic until she learns he is not Jewish. Now she tries harder to meet someone who is Jewish so she can distance herself from Dan. Unfortunately, the harder she tries, the worse her dates get...