Facing eviction, Rhea Morrison, a young grieving widow, must save her failing bakery. Her recently-injured twin sister, Raven, loans her money - stipulating Rhea attend a singles retreat to spy on Martin Lane, Raven's new love interest. Disgruntled, Rhea attends the retreat and is attracted to Martin. She discovers that Martin can help save her bakery. Pastor Martin laments over his secret, traumatic past mistakes. He's destined to lead his father's church, despite blatant rejection. He can't love Rhea - he's yet to forgive himself for his past, and if Rhea knew how he used to be, she would have no interest in pursuing a relationship with him. In spite of their shared attraction, he helps Rhea form a plan to save her business. Martin, a former successful bakery owner, can expertly create delicious pastry recipes. Rhea feels torn about her attraction to Martin - he's a pastor, and after her husband's death, she vowed to never get involved with another pastor. Plus, her twin sister, Raven, has strong feelings for Martin. Can Rhea let herself have romantic feelings for Martin - knowing it would hurt her sister? Can Martin and Rhea overcome their past so that they're free to love again?