Set in beautiful Austin, Texas, "Incredulity" is a contemporary story of Callie Fletcher, an official court reporter for Travis county, who meets and quickly falls in love with Dominic Jaxson, a Texas rancher. After several months of dating, Callie finds herself as happy and content as she was before she lost her husband to cancer several years prior, until one morning, when reporting the day's court proceedings, Jaxson is suddenly brought before the judge on murder charges.