Three friends, each of whom has been emotionally hurt, have dreams on Christmas Eve that bring healing. Maggie Maguire, who's been betrayed by an ex, finds herself in Ireland where Finn O'Byrne, Prince of the Fae, gives her hope. Elizabeth Shelton, who has little sympathy for women who don't break glass ceilings, finds herself in Victorian England...as a maid. Broc Haden, the warlock duke of the castle, helps her see the light. Caroline Campbell, whose husband was killed in war, is transported to Scotland just before the fatal battle of Culloden where Gavin McLean, a shapeshifting warrior, helps her overcome her loss. It is only when the three women meet for lunch after Christmas that they realize the three men sitting at the bar are the heroes from their dreams.