Clayton and Tilden Investigations' fourth case deals with a young girl from Middlebury, Vermont, who went missing in the early 1960's. The recent discovery of the girl's diary provides one small clue to her disappearance: she may have been kidnapped. Jack and Yolanda travel to several small towns, searching cold case files for any clue that might help them solve the case. Early in the case they realize that they might have identified the person responsible, but they lack any solid evidence that can link him to the crime. As they continue to unravel the string of clues, they become aware that they have uncovered a web of pure evil, a crime so malevolent that went far beyond a simple kidnapping.