Who is murdering the women who played on a championship basketball team twenty years ago? Sheriff Lexie searches for the sin that put the women on a kill list. Lexie's investigation intensifies when a local woman dies, and the citizens blame her for the death. When she discovers there are three secrets instead of one, she fears more will die while the investigation goes in multiple directions. Lexie's dilemma is further magnified by the fact that one of the women appears destined to be First Lady of the United States-provided she doesn't die first.