Strange things are happening in Malvern-and Finley, Dean, and Dale seem to be the only ones noticing. Flower pots are missing, houses are being robbed, and the infamous middle school fountain is suddenly gone.
When their investigating leads to Sable, Finley and her friends agree that it seems like she knows more than she's saying.
But with strict rules from Finley's mom, Rusty's constant bullying, and nothing in common between everything that's been stolen, will Finley solve the mystery before it's too late? Or, will she be forced to give up?