Encore in Bloomington, MN

Eminem
took a hiatus after the release of his first motion picture,
8 Mile
, in late 2002, but it never seemed like he went away. Part of that is the nature of celebrity culture, where every star cycles through gossip columns regardless of whether they have a project in the stores or theaters, and part of it is that
Marshall Mathers
kept busy, producing records by his proteges
D12
,
Obie Trice
, and
50 Cent
-- all hit albums -- with the latter turning into the biggest new
hip-hop
star of 2003. All this activity tended to obscure the fact that
hadn't released a full-length album of new material since
The Eminem Show
in early summer 2002, and that two and a half years separated that album and its highly anticipated sequel,
Encore
. As the title suggests,
is a companion piece to
the way that
The Marshall Mathers LP
mirrored
The Slim Shady LP
, offering a different spin on familiar subjects. Where his first two records dealt primarily with personas and characters, his second two records deal with what those personas have wrought, which tends to be intrinsically less interesting than the characters themselves, since it's dissecting the aftermath instead of causing the drama. On
that kind of self-analysis was perfectly acceptable, since
was on the top of his game as both a lyricist and rapper; his insights were vibrant and his music was urgent. Unfortunately,
is not the flipside of
as much as it is its negative image, where everything that was a strength has been turned into a handicap this time around. Musically,
Show
didn't innovate, but it didn't need to:
and his mentor,
Dr. Dre
, had achieved cruising altitude, and even if they weren't offering much that was new, the music sounded fresh and alive. Here, the music is staid and spartan, built on simple unadorned beats and keyboard loops. While some songs use this sound to its advantage and a few others break free --
"Yellow Brick Road"
is a tense, cinematic production -- the overall effect of these stark, black-and-white productions it to make
seem hermetically sealed, to make
sound isolated from the outside world. This impression is only enhanced by
Em
's choice of lyrical subjects throughout the album. Instead of documenting his life, or the shifts in his psyche, he's decided to chronicle what's happened to him over the past the two years and refute every charge that's made it into the papers. This is quite a bit different than his earlier albums, when he embellished and exaggerated his life, when his relationship with his estranged wife,
Kim
, turned into an outlaw
ballad
, when his frenetic insults, cheap shots, and celeb baiting had a surreal, hilarious impact. Here,
is plainspoken and literal, intent on refuting every critic from
Benzino
at
The Source
to
Triumph the Insult Comic Dog
, who gets an entire song (
"Ass Like That"
) devoted to him. It's a bizarre move that seems all the more humorless when you realize that the loosest, funniest song -- the first single,
"Just Lose It"
-- is a sideswipe at
Michael Jackson
, the easiest target
has yet hit. And that's the major problem with
: it sounds as if
is coasting, resting on his laurels, and never pushing himself into interesting territory. Since he's a talented artist, there are moments scattered across the record that do work, whether it's full songs or flights of phrase in otherwise limp tracks, and that's enough to make it worth a spin, but
never resonates the way his first three endlessly fascinating albums do. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine