Although she is known primarily as an interpretive singer,
Judy Collins
has been placing her occasional compositions on her albums dating back to the inclusion of
"Albatross,"
"Sky Fell,"
and
"Since You Asked"
(aka
"Since You've Asked"
) on
Wildflowers
in 1967. The songs have appeared without fanfare, and yet their quality (consider
"My Father"
on 1968's
Who Knows Where the Time Goes
,
"Secret Gardens"
on 1973's
True Stories and Other Dreams
, and
"Born to the Breed"
on 1975's
Judith
) always suggested that, if only
Collins
were more prolific, she might join the ranks of the singer/songwriters whose work she celebrated in her cover recordings. Another suggestion, of course, was that if somebody just gathered together the songs she had written and recorded, it would make quite an album.
Born to the Breed: A Tribute to Judy Collins
isn't that album exactly; it's a disc on which a group of different artists perform
' songs. The word "tribute" is perhaps ill-advised, not because the artists are not paying tribute -- they are -- but because this is a disc organized by
herself for her own record label, and calling it a tribute gives it an air of hubris; one doesn't usually put together one's own tributes, any more than one throws one's own birthday party. On the other hand,
certainly has an interest in promoting her own songs, and the album functions as a kind of glorified publisher's demo for that purpose. Of course, that understates the case heavily. Publishers generally do not get the likes of
Joan Baez
Shawn Colvin
Chrissie Hynde
Dolly Parton
Bernadette Peters
Rufus Wainwright
Jimmy Webb
Dar Williams
to tout their wares. That these artists were willing to participate is in itself a tribute to
, and they show her work off to good effect, usually by applying their own styles to the material.
' songs are craftsmanlike efforts that are varied in form and subject matter, from the personal reflection on her son that is
to a first-person story-song like
"My Father,"
and on to politically driven pieces like
"Song to Sarajevo."
But they are always carefully written and highly poetic (as
Leonard Cohen
's recitation of the lyrics to
at the end demonstrates), and they boast flowing, classically influenced melodies that usually seem to have been written on the piano. That compilation album of
singing
should be taken up sometime, but until then
Born to the Breed
will serve as a collection that demonstrates the singer is an excellent songwriter as well. ~ William Ruhlmann