When a painting by legendary artist Thomas Farkleberry is stolen from the art gallery where Tyler's mother works, Tyler's mind races to the whispered conversation he overheard on the night of the big gala. But when his mother dismisses Tyler's suspicions, he and his friends, Melanie, Amanda, Tubby, and Dontrelle, decide to take the investigation into their own hands. Can they crack the case before their parents discover what they are up to?