Raymond Bennett had everything a college student would want: enough charisma to charm any girl, intelligence in the classroom, and immense popularity in Alpha Theta Rho, the most prestigious fraternity at Greenville University. That's why everyone is as confused as they are shocked when he commits suicide on April 11th, leaving no note behind. Well, everyone except the members of Alpha Theta Rho, who are fully aware of what happened two nights prior, on April 9th. ATR's usually untouchable fraternity brothers must stop at nothing to conceal their deadly secret. Through a series of shocking twists and flashbacks, it becomes clear that none of the ATR brothers were ever whom they claimed to be. They're all to blame.